Tuesday, December 28, 2010
PtE Adjectives
Pliny the Elder's scholarliness is without doubt, considering his endeavors into natural science and other academic fields. Exhibiting this trait is an excerpt from Pliny the Younger's letter in lines 24 and 25, talking about the cloud, "Magnum propiusque noscendum, ut eruditissimo viro, visum". Pliny the Elder realized, due to his scholarly capability, that such a massive and unusual thing was definitely worthy to be looked at closer. He was very studious, so much that he ran straight into danger in order to gain new knowledge.
This, however, gave way to him being impulsive. Yes he was scholarly and being so wanted to study this strange occurrence, but it is very irrational to literally drive into the face of peril without thinking about it. At once, after seeing this cloud, with no second guessing, "Iubet Liburnicam aptari" (line 26). This is a very impulsive thing to do. Yes this gigantic cloud may be worthy of studying but at the same time nothing good can come of a massively widespread cloud that seems to overtake the island itself. Deciding to go in his boat at the first sight of this cloud is extremely impulsive.
Lastly, Pliny the Elder seems very caring. On top of wanting to go into danger for scholarly purposes, he also does it to save his friends. What started as a mission for scholarly advancement turned into a rescue mission, "Vertit ille consilium et quod studioso animo incohaverat obit maximo" (line 31). And on top of this, when death seems the only option, he puts aside any fear he may have in order to secure the minds of his friends that he's trying to save, "...lotus accubat, cenat aut hilaris aut, quod est aeque magnum, similis hilari" (lines 50 to 51). He ate happily either because he himself was happy or in order to have the others around him be happy.
For these reasons, Pliny the Elder is scholarly, impulsive, and caring. He is scholarly and caring due to his goals for heading to Stabiae, and impulsive for making such a rash decision at the very beginning.
Monday, December 6, 2010
The Letter of Pliny's Intent (on Christians)
Pliny seems to believe the Christians are not a bad people. He says their rituals are "prOmiscuum tamen et innoxium" (line 34), so he must not hate them. If you hadn't had any direct contact with the Christians and had only read Pliny's letter, you wouldn't think Christians are that bad and would get the impression that Pliny isn't scared of them either. I think Pliny is trying to lessen the fear Romans have for Christians and make Romans realize they can't just go and kill all the Christians because that won't work. Pliny is trying to make the Romans feel how he feels so that this may be corrected, not worsened. Pliny is very smart.
Sunday, November 7, 2010
Apuleius: Allegory of soul and desire
Apuleius’ Cupid and Psyche may be read as an allegorical tale of the union between Soul and Desire, producing Pleasure. This happens literally and metaphorically. Cupid and Psyche, the manifestations of desire and the soul, actually do get married and give birth to a child named Pleasure. This isn’t all that happens, however. This story really stands for when the soul (that thing which makes human beings alive and able to feel emotions) receives their true desire (whatever really makes them happy), true pleasure is felt. Pleasure is that feeling of joy or bliss that can only be accomplished when one has attained their genuine desire. Psyche, the human soul, goes through much toil and trouble to get her lover. Cupid goes through many pains in the heavens to receive his lover. Both, after hard and diligent work, legitimately and eternally get their true pleasure when they’re given their daughter, Pleasure. According to Epicurean philosophy, true hedonis (pleasure) can only be reached through the leveling out of pleasure and pain, with pleasure outweighing pain.
Psyche does go through many a misfortune to achieve her maximum happiness, voluptas. She goes through much anxiety dreading being taken away by some monster, falls in love but again goes into terrible anxiety thinking her lover is a beast, tries to kill herself but fails, is sent on three crazy and impossible missions by Venus in order to be able to see Cupid, and finally is almost left to die after opening Proserpina’s box. Psyche goes through the pain and the trouble so that she may be with her lover. After many dangers and being on the verge of death, she does get her voluptas, her baby named Pleasure, the summit of happiness in Epicurean philosophy.
Cupid does the same. He knows what destruction will come if Psyche is convinced by her sisters to look upon his face and is tortured by the anxiety but relents and allows Psyche to see them, is deeply hurt to wake up to Psyche looking upon his face and kissing him (meaning she sees him, clearly), is forced to leave her, comes to save her, then goes on trial in the heavens in order to marry her. After this trouble and pursuit of happiness, though, she is made immortal, they are married, and given voluptas, their daughter Pleasure, that peak of Epicurean philosophy most sought after.
Therefore, Apuleius’ Cupid and Psyche is an allegorical tale of the soul marrying desire and receiving voluptas. As in Epicurean philosophy, true pleasure is reached through constant trying and effort, and that is exactly what Cupid and Psyche do. In the end, as Epicurean philosophy would permit after such hard work, they birth their daughter Pleasure, and so reach their true happiness; they experience true hedonis and voluptas. Once the soul gets their desire, according to Epicurean philosophy, true happiness and 'pleasure' is experienced. It's all about balancing pleasure and pain, as Epicurean philosophy says. You can't constantly have temporary pleasures without putting the effort in to have some pain, because that's not true happiness; but at the same time going through so much pain and torture without any pleasure isn't happines either. You have to have balance, like Cupid and Psyche, and then you can get your hedonis, that true Voluptas.
Tuesday, October 26, 2010
The Sisters' Punishment: Just?
Next, what they did was deliberate. They planned it from the beginning and guided Psyche into the trap. Perhaps if they had truly been scared for Psyche's life and told her to kill the monster, they wouldn't have deserved such a fate. But they had planned it, and they were not scared for Pysche's life. It was pure jealousy. In translation, from Chapter 4, the sisters say "We'll teach her that we're not her slaves but her elder sisters. So for the present let's return to our husbands and our poor mediocre houses; and then after thoroughly digesting the situation let's return equipped to lessen her pride." There's no arguing it, the sisters intended to bring Psyche down, they flat out say it! There's no room for discretion, their intent is undeniable.
On top of this, after Psyche had been left by Cupid, they were ridiculously quick to forget about her problems and try to marry Cupid for themselves. In translation, from Chapter 9, "No sooner had Psyche finished speaking than the other, pricked-on by ravening rash lust and rankling jealousy, rushed out..and then taking ship she proceeded with all speed to the crag as of old." Psyche had barely finished speaking and she ran off! The same with the other one, "Psyche gave her the same misunderstanding; and the womanm lured by the hope of supplanting her sisterm dashed off to the crag and fell into the same death." Neither sister had the slightest drop of sympathy, let alone any emotion other than jealousy and greed. Therefore, both deserved the horrible death they got.
The sisters had no reason to be jealous, planned the evil plan with deliberate intent, and afterwards, didn't even show or feel any pity for poor Psyche. For these reasons, coupled with their undeniable evil, their punishment is just. If anything, they should have been tortured, and the only way their punishment isn't just is because it wasn't as harsh as it should have been.
Sunday, October 17, 2010
Cupid and Psyche - fear
Sunday, October 3, 2010
Cupid and Psyche chp. 1-3
Sunday, September 26, 2010
Cupid and Psyche Chapter Two Q#4
Psyche's funeral marriage is very dismal. First of all, it's intended for her to be taken away by some "vipereum malum" (line 14), which is not the most pleasant thing. There are also many more authorial choices setting the sad and gloomy atmosphere of her funeral marriage. Her mother and father "lamentantur dies plurimos" (line 16), putting the foundation down for the reader's sympathy for them. In addition, the torch that was supposed to light the way in the happy marriage procession "atro cinere marcescit", another very dismal and literally dark effect. On top of this, nobody is happily singing during the procession but the marriage hymn finishes in "lugubris ululatus", which more pity emerges from. And, personally, the most upsetting and flat out depressing part of this chapter that most definitely underlines the sadness of her funeral marriage, Psyche wipes her tears with her own veil! "puella nuptura deterget lacrimas ipso suo flammeo" (line 20). Also, Psyche does not get ready for a marriage but she attends to "exsequias suas". Being called a funeral marriage, it is to be expected that it will not be a very happy occasion. Apuleius definitely gets the point across that this is sad: there is crying, everybody is described as "miser" or "misella" or any other synonym for sad, and poor Psyche has to wiper her tears with her veil while preparing for her last rites, not even a marriage.
